Who is the most underrated and overrated player in the premiership

[callyno3]

Let the debate begin :). Everybody would probably go for steve finnan as most underrated. I think Ryan neilsen of blackburn is one of the most underrated players. with Rio and his brother Anton Ferdinand and Pederson of blackburn prob some of the most overrated players .
Who's next ???

[armaghred]

Underrated for me has to be matt taylor,overrated has to be the big donkey rio and gary styles.

[megager]

Most Over-rated....C Ronaldo. He is good, but comparisons with best and maradona are laughable. Plus he looks like a sleazy git, so just for that he gets my vote.


Most under-rated....Steve Taylor of Newcastle is a great playyer, but doesnt get recognition of tosspot Ferdinand. ( would love to sign him).

[yodabenitez]

Ferdinand R most overrated player in the history of football.
Finnan S most underrated player..................................

[megager]

I should probably qualify my post. I would like to sign Steven Taylor, not ferdinand. If we ever were to sign either ferdinand I'd die just so I can turn in my grave.

[yodabenitez]

Laughing out loud...class post!

[stevieg]

Underrated - Shay Given

Overrated - Frank Lampard

[megager]

Underrated - Shay Given

Overrated - Frank Lampard

Overeaten - Frank Lampard

[gav003]

Probably not going to be popular here- and it's slightly off topic but...deep breath... I thought the bluenoses were harshly done by in the PFA awards this year. Think there was a strong argument for Lescott & Arteta in the team of the season.

I reckon Lescott is an extremely under rated player who performed very well week in week out for them.

Finnan of course is without doubt the most under rated player in the Prem. Id also make a case for Brad Friedel.